Gender Peer Effects: Evidence from a Quasi-Random Classroom Assignment Policy∗
نویسندگان
چکیده
The literature on gender peer effects documents that exposure to opposite gender peers can lead to higher academic performances for boys but lower outcomes, especially in math, for girls. This result can be explained by two distinct exposure effects. One is inside-class time exposure (e.g. boy peers are disruptive and lower the quality of student-teacher interactions) and the other is outside-class time exposure effects that arise through social interactions with peers outside class periods (e.g. boy peers negatively influence other peers’ decisions on study efforts). I use student-level data from a Korean high school that, at the beginning of each academic year, quasi-randomly assigned students to either a single-sex or a coeducational homeroom. Students assigned to the same homeroom have the same class schedule throughout the year and take classes together in their homeroom — except for tracking subjects, math and English, where students are assigned to separate classrooms based on gender and academic skill in each subject. I find significant increases in girls’ native language test scores when the class is taught in a coeducational environment and a girl’s prior performance in native language was above her cohort’s average performance. However, I find no significant effect of assignment to a coeducational classroom on boys’ and girls’ academic achievements in tracking subjects. These findings suggest that gender peer effects are mostly due to exposure to opposite gender peers during class time. JEL Codes: I21, J16. ∗I am extremely grateful to Seema Jayachandran, Lori Beaman, and Jonathan Guryan for providing helpful comments and suggestions. I am thankful to Byungsuk Lee and Yoon Kyoung Lee for providing support with data collection. All errors are my own. †Email: [email protected] Web: sites.northwestern.edu/spa136
منابع مشابه
Peer Effects in Microenvironments: The Benefits of Homogeneous Classroom Groups
Many believe that classroom interactions play an important role in students’ academic achievement, but there is little evidence on peer effects within sub-classroom groups. We exploit random seat assignment in a Chinese middle school to estimate how the gender of neighboring students affects a student’s academic achievement. We find that being surrounded by five females rather than five males i...
متن کاملIdentification of peer effects with missing peer data: Evidence from Project STAR
Identification of Peer Effects with Missing Peer Data: Evidence from Project STAR This paper studies peer effects on student achievement among first graders randomly assigned to classrooms in Tennessee’s Project STAR. The analysis uses previously unexploited pre-assignment achievement measures available for 60 percent of students. Data are not missing at random, making identification challengin...
متن کاملThe Impact of School and Classroom Gender Composition on Educational Achievement∗
We estimate the impact of peer gender composition on student achievement, exploiting the random assignment of Korean middle school students to single-sex schools, coeducational schools with single-sex classes, and coeducational schools with mixed-gender classes. Male students attending coeducational schools with single-sex classes perform worse than boys in mixed-gender classes, while those ass...
متن کاملSchool Context and the Gender Gap in Educational Achievement
Today, boys generally underperform relative to girls in schools throughout the industrialized world. Building on theories about gender identity and reports from prior ethnographic classroom observations, we argue that school environment channels conceptions of masculinity in peer culture, fostering or inhibiting boys’ development of anti-school attitudes and behavior. Girls’ peer groups, by con...
متن کاملAcademic Peer Effects with Different Group Assignment Policies: Residential Tracking versus Random Assignment∗
A growing literature in the economics of education emphasizes the importance of peer effects in determining students’ academic outcomes. Most of the existing empirical literature uses natural experiments in which students are randomly assigned to peer groups to identify the causal effect of peer characteristics. However, their results provide no direct evidence regarding the policy-relevant pro...
متن کامل